What is the meaning of aristophaness speech from platos. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium flashcards. Because he is famous as a comic playwright, aristophanes s listeners likely expect his speech to be funny. Cydathenaeum, was a comic playwright of ancient athens and a poet of old attic comedy. Written 2,400 years ago, platos philosophical novella, symposium, includes one of the weirdest and most charming explanations of why people fall in love ever invented.
Aristophanes, a comic poet, gives the first speech, and the second is given by socrates. Tumblr is a place to express yourself, discover yourself, and bond over the stuff you love. Per your objections ill work on crafting a new section for the article body. Even if platos fellow athenians did not know that the party which celebrated agathons victory occurred in 416 bc, they would be able to infer from the names of the guests that the gathering took place a short time before the disastrous sicilian expedition in 415414. Pursuit of love in aristophaness theory of romantic love. A reading of platos symposium 6 after finishing dinner, pausanias, aristophanes, erixymachus, and agathon voice a collective desire to abstain from heavy drinking for the night, the festivities of the previous day having left them in rather imperfect condition. Start studying aristophaness speech from platos symposium.
Get an answer for what is the meaning of aristophaness speech from platos symposium. Plato, allan bloom wrote, is the most erotic of philosophers, and his symposium is one of the greatest works on the nature of love ever written. Agreeing with agathon that love is deeply connected to the ideas of goodness and beauty, socrates nonetheless insists the connection is more complex than agathon has suggested. Apr 02, 2015 written 2,400 years ago, platos philosophical novella, symposium, includes one of the weirdest and most charming explanations of why people fall in love ever invented. Of all the speeches given in this work, aristophanes had one of the most interesting theories. Each civilization develops its own views and attitudes on sexuality and love. Translated by benjamin jowett fromcollected works of plato, 4th edition, oxford u. Almost everything can have love and it is of vital importance in his field of medicine. Does plato s symposium seem to validate or to undercut foucault andor halperin in the matter of whether people generally have, most places and most times, understood sexuality more or less the same way. Press, 1953 189c189d p 520 to 193d193e page 525 1 aristophanes professed to open another vein of discourse. Aristophaness myth in platos symposium to construct his argument aristophanes relies on a myth which recounts the beginning of humanity and the circumstances of the simultaneous birth of love and sexuality vii. As a result of years of rereading and teaching aristophanes, he realized that the clouds could not be defended in an analysis of that play in isolation. Platos symposium discusses the everpresent, complicated, and enigmatic idea of love. Mar 31, 2008 aristophaness speech from platos symposium written 360 b.
On a more serious note, the second speech addresses the origin of eros and his. He tells you the picture is black and white, then he brings you in so close that it all turns gray. The attainability of love platos symposium offers a wide variety of viewpoints surrounding love. Platos symposium is a book of speeches given in honor of eros, the god of love. Benardetes on platos symposium and allan blooms provocative. So says aristophanes in his fantastical account of the origins of love in platos symposium. One must put two human beings back to back and imagine that in the beginning they formed a single being. The general understanding is that there are multiple forms of love, and whichever is engaged in will help dictate the status of. Having finally recovered from his hiccuping fit, aristophanes offers his own speech on love, beginning with a mild joke at eryximachus s expense. Press, 1953 189c189d p 520 to 193d193e p 525aristophanes professed to open another vein of discourse. Essay on an analysis of aristophanes s speech from plato.
In trying to find an answer to this inquiry, plato writes his philosophical symposium, a book comprising a story within a story, within a story that deals with the topics of knowledge and love. Dec 22, 2011 platos symposium is a book of speeches given in honor of eros, the god of love. Mar 22, 2018 in the middle of plato s dialogue the symposium, aristophanes follows several others, all of whom have been tasked with giving speeches on love or eros. Instead, those round and speedy people, who managed to challenge the gods and bring us an especially satisfying and comic metaphor for love, tell us a truth about ourselves. First he explains that long ago there were three types of human beings. Start studying aristophanes s speech from plato s symposium. The main theme of the dialogue symposium by plato and aristophaness lysistrata is love. Jul 28, 2009 aristophaness speech from platos symposium july 28, 2009 transalchemy leave a comment go to comments translated by benjamin jowett from collected works of plato, 4th edition, oxford u. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Platos symposium aristophaness speech on love in primal times people were globular spheres who wheeled around like clowns doing cartwheels. The dramatic setting occurs among a group of athenians gathered at agathons house in athens to celebrate his victory. In the symposium, the dialectic exists among the speeches. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium 2971 words. French animated adaptation of plato s symposium 189d191d with english subtitles.
Aristophanes, a comic poet, gives the first speech, and the second is given by socrates the first speech tells a humorous history of mankind and how it became whole, addressing gender issues and sexua. The third speech is given by a doctor, eryximachus, who extends the idea of love beyond interpersonal relationships, claiming love is found in the coexistence of opposites, the harmony of nature. E in the house of agathon in the first place, let me treat of the nature of man and what has happened to it. French animated adaptation of platos symposium 189d191d with english subtitles. Each speech builds on ideas that will lead to the conclusion made in diotimas speech.
In this book strauss tells the other half poetrys side. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium written 360 b. The creatures tried to scale the heights of heaven and planned to set upon the gods. Aristophanes speech from platos symposium read by a poetry. I borrowed a french animated adaptation of platos symposium 189d191d from director. Mankind, he said, judging by their neglect of him, have. Aristophanes s myth in plato s symposium to construct his argument aristophanes relies on a myth which recounts the beginning of humanity and the circumstances of the simultaneous birth of love and sexuality vii. In symposium, most people in the speech believe that love is a god and something good thing, love is a great god, wonderful in many ways to gods and men, and most marvelous of. The genres borrowed in his speech are of the broadest in the book. His theory referred to a myth in which at one point humans were very powerful. Throughout the book, each speech gives diverse and sometimes contradictory ideas on the nature of love, its benefits, its origin, and the different types of love.
Essay on an analysis of aristophanes s speech from plato s. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium essay 2956 words. Jan 08, 2017 platos famous dialogue, the symposium, takes place the day after the tragic poet, agathon, wins his first and only award at the lenaia in 416 bc, the year before alcibiadess failed quest to sicily. Its where your interests connect you with your people. Here and throughout the book reckford illustrates aristophanes form of comedy with analogies to rabelais, shakespeare, charlie chaplin, alice in wonderland. The symposium, written around 370 bc, is the bestknown work by plato, the preeminent philosopher of antiquity. In this essay, i approach the question of comedy and tragedy, as well as their relation to philosophy, in the platonic dialogues through a focus on the comic poet aristophanes speech in platos symposium. In platos symposium, aristophanes delivers his speech in the form of a myth once upon a time, there were three kinds of human beings. The nature of love in platos symposium 1526 words 7 pages. Once upon a time, all human beings were double creatures, each with two heads, two bodies and eight limbs. Socrates s discourse on love is the centerpiece of the dialogue and, in part, a refutation of agathon s onesided speech on the topic. This startling and original study emerged from kenneth rockfords wish to vindicate aristophanes clouds against detractors. Socalled from being discourse over wine after a banquet, it depicts a friendly contest of extemporaneous speeches about eros, the god of love, between some mostlyfamous athenians. The symposium is a philosophical text by plato dated c.
Perhaps not everyone would agree with that statement but, i suspect, if the book were called platos gay symposium about homosexual sex some people would try and argue that it was actually mostly about heterosexuality. Once upon a time, all human beings were double creatures, each with two heads, two bodies and. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the symposium and what it means. Be this as it may, platos symposium and republic especially republic x where socrates bans the poets from his just city tells only half the story philosophys side. May, 2017 plato s symposium aristophanes s speech doccolad. The men include the philosopher socrates, the general and political figure alcibiades, and the comic playwright aristophanes. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium essay example. Before turning to aristophaness odd speech, lets set the. Aristophanes speech in the philosopher platos symposium, written around 400 bc, embodied the origin of eros. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium flashcards quizlet. Instead he uses a strange but moving fable to explain the origins and nature of love. Symposium by plato summary and analysis of the speech of aristophanes aristophanes speech focuses on human nature and a mythical account of how love plays out among humans. Aristophanes prefaces his speech, once his hiccups have subsided, by saying that he will speak in a different way than those that proceeded him. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
The original human nature was not like the present, but different. In his book socrates and aristophanes 1966, strauss provides one. Love in platos symposium and aristophaness lysistrata. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium transalchemys. Read the fulltext online edition of aristophanes oldandnew comedy vol. Platos famous dialogue, the symposium, takes place the day after the tragic poet, agathon, wins his first and only award at the lenaia in 416 bc, the year before alcibiadess failed quest to sicily. Before starting his speech, aristophanes warns the group that his eulogy to love may be more absurd than funny. Aristophanes speech in the philosopher plato s symposium, written around 400 bc, embodied the origin of eros love, sexual attraction, and desire. It makes sense according to aristophaness speech from platos symposium, where she tells us that in the beginning, we were all attached to our soul mate, after the division the two parts of man, each desiring his other half, came together, and throwing their arms about one another, entwined in mutual embraces, longing to grow into one. Plato gives this trippy exegesis to the playwright aristophanes, who appears as a character in the book. Start studying aristophaness speech from plato s symposium. The characters and the settings are to some degree based on history, but they. Platos symposium aristophaness speech what is the nature of love.
Aristophaness central speech in the symposium, which suggests that aristophanes was a secret friend and admirer of philosophy conceived in the platonic manner, as an erotic search for the truth of nature, beneath aristophaness religiously pious and culturally conservative veneer. Aristophanes speech in platos symposium volume 86 k. Plato symposium study guide, ancient sexuality and gender. Symposium study guide contains a biography of plato, literature essays, a complete etext, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full. Following agathons speech, socrates, with agathons permission and cooperation, deconstructs his speech. Agathon replies that socrates is trying to fluster him by suggesting that everyone expects a great speech from him. The crazy and charming theory of love in platos symposium. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The symposium is, like all of plato s dialogues, fiction. Because he is famous as a comic playwright, aristophaness listeners likely expect his speech to be funny. Leo strauss is one of a handful of political philosophers to turn his gaze to the political thought of aristophanes. The first speech tells a humorous history of mankind and how it became whole, addressing gender issues and sexuality.
He describes love as possessing beauty and good things. Symposium aristophaness speech summary course hero. Love is interpreted in many different aspects and beliefs in both stories. It depicts a friendly contest of extemporaneous speeches given by a group of notable men attending a banquet. According to the play, a group of sophisticated and. These provide the most valuable examples of a genre of. His speech is a parody of the style of oratory of gorgias, his teacher. Having finally recovered from his hiccuping fit, aristophanes offers his own speech on love, beginning with a mild joke at eryximachuss expense. This essay onaristophaness speech from platos symposium will help you to deliver your best academic writing. Benardete s on plato s symposium and allan bloom s provocative. Plato gives this trippy exegesis to the playwright aristophanes, who appears as a character in the book before turning to aristophaness odd speech, lets set the stage. Symposium by plato the speech of aristophanes summary and. Platos symposium gives us a look into how philosophers of the past viewed romantic love. In aristophaness speech from platos symposium, the primeval man had, four hands and the same number of feet, one head with two faces, looking opposite ways.
Oct, 2009 platos symposium aristophaness speech on love in primal times people were globular spheres who wheeled around like clowns doing cartwheels. Symposium by plato, part of the internet classics archive. A reading of plato s symposium 6 after finishing dinner, pausanias, aristophanes, erixymachus, and agathon voice a collective desire to abstain from heavy drinking for the night, the festivities of the previous day having left them in rather imperfect condition. The folklore and fable are exemplified in the mood taken on by aristophanes storytellinghis speech is not pedantic like eryximachuss, but rather exudes the feeling of being an old wives tale. Quite a few comments have been posted about symposium. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading lysistrata.
Aristophaness speech from platos symposium translated by benjamin jowett from collected works of plato, 4th edition, oxford u. Before turning to aristophaness odd speech, lets set the stage. Aristophaness speech from platos symposium essay 2956. Aristophanes speech in platos symposium the journal of. The concept of a soul mate has roots in greek mythology. May 17, 2007 speech of aristophanes discours daristophane. They agree that love pursues beauty and good things and that one does not desire what one has. The other major ideas from socratess speechlove as a chasing after immortality, and love as an ascent toward pure beautyare among the most important and influential in platos works.
Plato sets the action in a symposium hosted by the poet agathon to celebrate his first victory in a dramatic competition, the dionysia of 416 bc. Socrates answers that, having seen agathon at the festival, he knows that agathon can speak with great confidence before large crowds. Eleven of his forty plays survive virtually complete. This new edition brings together the english translation of the renowned plato scholar and translator, seth benardete, with two illuminating commentaries on it.
645 919 1073 681 898 682 784 64 1588 324 421 1177 1412 123 78 885 1101 1016 703 1583 372 1382 1568 1054 73 633 900 1166 942 13 471 865 562 625